Money
Luca Bonura · Founder & Editor
Published · Updated

HMRC is writing to builders whose CIS and tax returns don't match

For limited companies that pay subcontractors under the Construction Industry Scheme: what HMRC's letters from 5 November 2026 to 18 January 2027 check, and what to look at before one lands.

5 min read
A kitchen table with a hard hat, a laptop and invoices, and a red envelope lying across two forms that do not line up.AI-generated illustration
1
What happened

What is HMRC checking, and when do the letters arrive?

HMRC is comparing two returns: your Corporation Tax return and your monthly CIS returns. On 4 November 2026 it added a new entry to its official list of genuine letters: "From 5 November 2026 up to and including 18 January 2027, HMRC may write to you" (gov.uk). Two situations trigger a letter. You've put subcontractor costs on your Corporation Tax return "but you have not yet submitted a Construction Industry Scheme return", or the costs "do not match the subcontractor costs on your Construction Industry Scheme return". What the letter asks: "If you receive a letter, we'll explain any issue we've found." HMRC will "then ask you to correct your return or send evidence to show your Corporation Tax return is correct." This is a second campaign. HMRC is also writing to contractors it believes may have applied the wrong deduction rate between 6 April 2025 and 5 April 2026. Its guidance for those letters was published on 18 September 2026. Those letters have a reference starting with CFSS and their own guidance (gov.uk). Don't mix the two up.

2
What it means for your business

Who could get one of these letters (and who won't)?

Limited companies that are CIS contractors, because the check runs against the Corporation Tax return. That's the roofing Ltd with three regular subbies, the small building company, the electrical firm that brings in a plasterer for bigger jobs. Here's the catch: a mismatch can be very ordinary. For example, a month where you paid a subbie but filed a nil return, or a payment booked in the accounts that never made it onto the CIS return. Not covered by this letter: sole traders and partnerships. They can be CIS contractors too, but they don't file a Corporation Tax return, and HMRC hasn't said they'll get a similar letter. Subcontractors who only receive CIS payments aren't the target either. Nor are shops, cafés and salons. No new rule, no new penalty. The letter is a nudge. The normal rules apply: CIS returns are due "by the 19th of every month following the last tax month", and late ones cost £100 after one day, £200 after two months, then £300 or 5% of the deductions, whichever is higher, at six months (gov.uk).

What you can do this week

What should you do before 18 January?

Check your CIS returns against your accounts now, before HMRC does it for you. HMRC's page gives no reply deadline or penalty for this letter, but a mistake you fix yourself is one less thing to explain. The short version: Two returns, one set of payments. They should tell the same story.

  • ✓This week: ask your accountant for the subcontractor costs on your last Corporation Tax return and add up the payments on your CIS monthly returns for the same period.
  • ✓Find the gaps: months with payments but a nil return, payments missing from the returns, or costs that aren't really subcontractor payments.
  • ✓Correct what's wrong. "Use the HMRC CIS online service to change or correct something on your return." A Corporation Tax return can usually be amended "within 12 months of the filing deadline", though "HMRC may charge you a penalty for errors" (gov.uk).
  • ✓If a letter comes, reply to it. Either correct the return or send evidence that yours is right. Keep subcontractor invoices and payment records together.
£100

Penalty for a CIS monthly return 1 day late

Source: gov.uk, "What you must do as a CIS contractor"

Common questions

Is the HMRC letter about CIS and Corporation Tax genuine?

Yes. HMRC added it to its official list of genuine letters on 4 November 2026. It says it may write between 5 November 2026 and 18 January 2027 if your Corporation Tax return shows subcontractor costs without a CIS return, or with costs that don't match. Check the gov.uk page before you reply.

What do contractors need to do about HMRC's CIS nudge letters?

Read which problem the letter names, then fix it or prove your figures. HMRC asks you "to correct your return or send evidence to show your Corporation Tax return is correct". For the separate wrong-rate letters (reference starting CFSS), follow HMRC's own guidance for those, published 18 September 2026.

What happens if I don't file a CIS return on time?

You pay a penalty. A monthly return 1 day late costs £100, 2 months late £200, and 6 months late £300 or 5% of the CIS deductions, whichever is higher. The same again at 12 months, and more after that. You can appeal within 30 days of the penalty notice.

Sources

  1. HMRC, "Check if a letter you've received from HMRC is genuine", Corporation Tax and CIS entry added 4 November 2026
  2. HMRC, "What you must do as a CIS contractor: file your monthly returns"
  3. HMRC, "Company Tax Returns: making changes"
  4. HMRC, "Report Construction Industry Scheme (CIS) contractor monthly return errors if you've received a letter from HMRC", 18 September 2026
Luca Bonura
Founder & Editor

Luca Bonura started selling online at 17 and funded his first business with 4:30am shifts in a bakery. He built his own product brand, watched it fail, and rebuilt as a freelance performance marketer for everyone from small shops to HelloFresh. Seeing how hard growth is even for people inside the industry, he founded Adlarion. He writes The Small Business Digest in plain English: the news he wished he'd had when starting out.

More from Luca →
A perk for readers
Xero logo
Xero: 90% off 6 months
Online accounting for small business

Invoicing, bank reconciliation and cash flow in one place.

See the deal →

Some perks earn us a commission. It never decides what we write. How we work