Law & Staff
Yusuf Gökce · Food & hospitality editor
Published · Updated

Compulsory service charge? Since April 2025 it goes in the price

For UK restaurants, cafés, pubs, salons and trades taking Christmas bookings: a service charge, booking fee or VAT the customer cannot avoid has to be inside the first price they see.

6 min read
A menu card, a bill on a small tray and a card reader on a restaurant table, with one line on the bill marked in red.AI-generated illustration

What is drip pricing on a menu or booking page?

Drip pricing is showing one price first and adding a charge the customer cannot avoid later. Since 6 April 2025, section 230 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 says the price a consumer is shown must be the total price, and that the total "includes any fees, taxes, charges or other payments that the consumer will necessarily incur". The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) applies that to hospitality in its price transparency guidance, CMA209. A menu counts, "including a physical menu card or a digital menu that can be accessed through the scanning of a QR code". Its list of mandatory charges names "mandatory cover or service charges at a restaurant" and "administration fees, however described, such as booking or processing fees". A line under the menu does not fix it. The CMA's summary for businesses says of mandatory charges: "Providing them separately will not normally be enough to comply with the law." So, in our own example, a Christmas menu at £45 a head with a compulsory 12.5% service charge should read £50.63 (our arithmetic: £45 × 1.125 = £50.625, rounded up).

Is a "discretionary" 12.5% service charge still allowed?

Yes, an optional service charge is still legal, but the CMA has not said how it treats a "discretionary" 12.5% already on the bill. CMA209 does not mention discretionary service charges or tips. An extra the customer can turn down may be shown separately, but "merely presenting a charge separately to the headline price or describing it as an extra service does not make it optional". Respondents to the CMA's consultation asked about "restaurant service charges" and "gratuities". The CMA replied in its summary of responses that "it would be impractical to address all the situations raised". The government said in its reply to a Parliament petition on 16 September 2026 that it "does not intend to prohibit hospitality businesses from adding optional service charges to bills", but you "must always make it clear on the bill or in communication with the consumer whether any tip automatically added to the bill is optional or mandatory". So the CMA has not settled the pre-added 12.5%. Its test is not the label, but whether the customer has to pay the charge to get the meal.

Who has to show the full price (and who doesn't)?

Every UK business that shows a price to consumers has to show the total price. The CMA says the rules apply "to anyone who sells, advertises, markets or otherwise promotes a product to customers" (CMA summary). That is the café with a chalkboard, the restaurant with a QR menu, the salon with a booking fee on its booking page, and the plumber quoting a household. VAT counts as a charge. If you are "quoting to someone who they know is a consumer", the CMA says traders "must always include VAT in the total price" (CMA209, paragraph 4.7). Not covered: price lists you give only to trade customers, which can leave VAT out. Extras a customer can turn down are not covered either. The CMA's example is a hotel that shows a room-only price and sells breakfast on top. Its café example goes the other way: a coffee with a 20p cup charge is listed at £3.70, with 20p off for customers who bring a cup. Germany has its own price rules.

How do you fix your Christmas menu, booking page and quotes?

Go through every place a customer sees a price and make the first number the full one, before your Christmas menu is printed or posted. There is no new deadline. The rule has applied since 6 April 2025, so check this week, while party menus are going out. The short version:

  1. 1This week: list every extra you add. Service charge, cover charge, booking fee, VAT. For each: can the customer say no and still buy?
  2. 2Build compulsory charges into each price. In our example, a £45 set menu with a compulsory 12.5% charge becomes £50.63 (our arithmetic). À la carte, raise each dish price. You may still show a breakdown.
  3. 3Put a flat booking fee into the advertised price. The CMA's example: a £20 ticket with a £2.50 fee is advertised as "from £22.50".
  4. 4If your service charge is optional, say so on the menu and the bill, and tell staff to take it off when asked.
  5. 5Check every copy before it goes out: printed menu, QR menu, website, booking page, social posts and household quotes (VAT included).

What can drip pricing cost you?

The CMA can fine a business directly, up to £300,000 or 10% of its turnover, whichever is higher, and order refunds. The Act caps a penalty at "£300,000 or, if higher, 10% of the total value of the turnover" of the business (section 182). Turnover includes "turnover both in and outside the United Kingdom" (section 204). Both sections have applied since 6 April 2025. A £3 fee was enough. The CMA announced on 15 April 2026 that it had fined the AA £4.2 million over its AA and BSM driving schools, because "a mandatory £3 booking fee was not included in the upfront price". The AA must also refund over £760,000 to more than 80,000 customers, about £9 each on average. Sarah Cardell, the CMA's chief executive, said: "If a fee is mandatory, the law is clear: it must be included in the price from the very start". The AA is a national firm, not a café. The rule it broke is the same one that applies to your menu.

Common questions

Is a service charge mandatory in the UK?

No. Adding one is your choice. The government calls how a business presents tipping options "a commercial decision, as long as they comply with consumer law". If you make the charge compulsory, it has to be inside the price customers see first. If it is optional, you must make that clear on the bill or when you tell the customer.

Will default service charges be banned?

Not for now. In its reply of 16 September 2026 to a Parliament petition, the government said it "does not consider that a further statutory prohibition is necessary at this time". The petition closed on 22 October 2026 with 10,647 signatures. How service charges are shared with staff falls under a separate law, the Employment (Allocation of Tips) Act 2023.

Can I charge customers extra for paying by card?

No, not consumers. CMA209 says the Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 "prevent merchants from charging a fee in addition to the advertised price of a transaction on the basis of a consumer's choice of payment instrument (eg credit card)". The price on your menu or quote is the price, whichever card the customer uses.

Do I have to show prices including VAT?

Yes, when the price is aimed at consumers. The CMA says a trader who is "advertising generally" or "quoting to someone who they know is a consumer" must "always include VAT in the total price". Only price lists made available to trade customers can leave VAT out. A quote to a household should show one total.

Sources

  1. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 230 (legislation.gov.uk) · in force 06 Apr 2025
  2. CMA, Unfair commercial practices: price transparency (CMA209), full guidance · 18 Nov 2025
  3. CMA, Providing clear and accurate information about prices: summary · 07 Jan 2026
  4. CMA, CMA209 summary of responses to the consultation · 18 Nov 2025
  5. UK Government response to petition 764909, Ban default service charges and pre-set digital tip screens in hospitality · 16 Sep 2026
  6. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 182 (legislation.gov.uk) · in force 06 Apr 2025
  7. Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, section 204 (legislation.gov.uk) · in force 06 Apr 2025
  8. CMA press release, CMA orders the AA and BSM driving schools to refund learner drivers over drip pricing · 15 Apr 2026
Yusuf Gökce
Food & hospitality editor

Yusuf helps run and scale a 55-store international food franchise - and has been the owner himself, with two of his own locations. He writes for the Digest on food, hospitality, and what it really takes to run a place.

More from Yusuf →
The 5-minute Digest

Get the next one in your inbox.

Our newsletter starts soon. No spam, unsubscribe in one click.

We only use your email for the Digest. Privacy